Wharfedale Preview and the Relegation Race
by Ross Tucknott
With nothing but victory in the Dales likely to be enough to save Redruth’s position in National One next season, we’re taking a quick look at how our opponents have fared themselves this season and what results need to occur to keep Cornish interest in the third tier of English rugby.
Wharfedale kick-started their season at our expense at the Recreation Ground in September, a 78th minute Andrew Hodgson try converted by Thomas Davidson enough to undermine earlier scores by Steve Kenward and Mark Bright, snatching a 15-16 victory. It was Wharfedale’s third successive win at the Rec: a feat unmanaged by any other team at this level.
However, the danger signs for the Dalesmen’s clunky campaign showed early as a two-point defeat at home to Cinderford started an unfortunate trend. With just 6 wins and 1 draw, only Otley have a worse home record this year. Other notable home defeats include Blaydon (13-15), Blackheath (14-21) and Launceston (10-12), whilst it recently took two converted tries in the 77th and 79th minutes to salvage a draw from what had been up until that point a complete capitulation to Sedgley Park.
The home supporters have not been subjected only to doom and gloom though. The season’s highlights for Wharfedale must include a compelling 43-24 destruction of Macclesfield and another last-gasp 79th minute converted Dan Solomi try to beat mercurial Cambridge 31-28.
Tries have been hard to come by for Wharfedale, having scored less than any other team so far this season (66), but this is only fractionally less per game than Redruth (2.357 versus 2.379). Unlike Redruth when it’s rained tries it’s poured tries, with Wharfedale securing 9 try bonus points as opposed to our 5. Fifty-three penalties has been what has kept their scoreboard ticking over: only Rosslyn Park have scored more of them.
Whafedale’s tries have been split remarkably evenly between forwards (30) and backs (31), meaning that they have the third highest forwards:backs tries ratio in the league after Coventry and Redruth. Dan Solomi heads the Dalesmen’s try scoring with 11, whilst Andrew Hodgson has 8 and Simon Horsfall 7. Talite Vaioleti, David Hughes, Rob Baldwin, Steve Graham and Chris Malherbe all have four between them.
| Time | 0-20m | 20-40m | 40-60m | 60-80m |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wharfedale tries scored (H) | 7 | 12 | 7 | 13 |
| Wharfedale tries scored (A) | 5 | 10 | 3 | 11 |
| Redruth tries conceded (A) | 7 | 20 | 15 | 19 |
Unlike other teams in the league, Wharfedale have a very distinct scoring pattern both home and away, scoring twice as many tries in the last 20 minutes of each half as they did in the first 20 minutes! Couple that with Redruth’s habit of conceding twice as frequently in the last 20 minutes of each half than the first 20 minutes of each half and a trip to the bookies suddenly seems in order…
Having talked about Wharfedale’s season so far, they seem a good place to start with discussing Redruth’s permutations of survival. The Dalesmen are five points clear of Redruth with a game in hand on 62 points, so only a 5-0 league point victory would put them in danger – Wharfedale would then be behind Redruth on games won (and possibly points difference too – this is the next criteria after games won). They (and we) would then only learn their fate after playing at Cinderford on 21st May, where a single bonus point would be enough to continue their status as the longest-running occupants of level 3 rugby. Verdict: As good as safe.
Cinderford too are not mathematically safe on 62 points either and two games in hand, but should Redruth grab 5 points this weekend then they would still be behind Cinderford on points difference (currently by 81 points). A point would guarantee the Forresters’ safety, but successive home games this weekend against Barking and next weekend against Cambridge might make that tricky, as well as possibly eroding their points difference to less than that of Redruth. Should they need it, they will then have the Wharfedale game to save themselves with both sides needing at most a point. Verdict: More chance of getting hit by lighting.
Blaydon might have done enough this weekend to keep themselves safe. A losing bonus point and restricting the Reds to two tries means that they sit on 59 points (2 ahead of us) with a game in hand, so a single victory would be enough no matter what. Even better for them, this weekend sees them host relegated Otley, so there is great expectation on the north-easterners to secure their status in style. Should they fail, they get a second shot at survival before heading back to work when they make the tiny trip to Tynedale for their derby game. Verdict: As good as safe
Sedgley Park once seemed the most likely team to be caught by Redruth, but recent performances have kept the great Mancunian escape artists with their heads above water (it took the restructuring of the Championship two years ago to relegate them before). Currently on 59 points with a game in hand, a win this weekend would guarantee their safety should Redruth win but a trip to Cambridge is perhaps not the best place to look for victory. Should the two teams finish the day on equal points then Redruth would leap-frog the Tigers on points difference (unless Redruth draw and Sedgley lose, in which case Sedgley stay ahead on games won). Sedgley’s game in hand is a home encounter with Macclesfield on the 7th of May, and a win would certainly keep them safe. Verdict: Still might have work to do – Macc county call-ups might be key? – but probably safe.
Redruth have had their fate held in the hands of others for the last couple of months, and that it’s coming down to the last game is a testament to the character of the players and coaches at the club. Whatever happens it’s been a great season: let’s just hope the next is just as good but for a different set of reasons! As for the game: can the last person leaving Redruth turn off the lights?!


